Tuesday, December 29, 2009

'Skins Eliminate Giants From Playoffs: Cowboys 17, Redskins 0

Arguably, one might say that the Redskins got the sweetest revenge against their rivals in New Jersey for sweeping them this year by deviously and surreptitiously exhibiting incompetence and ineptitude on every level against the Dallas Cowboys in a game that led to the Giants' elimination from post season contention. Another person might say, on the other hand, that all Redskins fans wanted was a win against Dallas to soothe the burn that this awful 2009 season has been.

  Instead, we got to watch our offense do jack-diddly-poo to the tune of zero points and zero entrances into the red zone. 

We got to watch Ganther run for 1.2 yards per carry or something like that.  We got to watch Campbell hold on to the ball after a play designed for a 3 step drop and throw and get sacked for a 15 yard loss.  We got to watch the offensive line get shoved around once again.  And we got to watch the Cowboys easily outcoach the Redskins who placed their safeties way too deep, allowing easy completions over the middle for 8-10 yards.

Watching this one wasn't as painful as watching the Giants game because the score didn't explode too much early on, and some admirable 4th and short stops by our defense made a come back technically possible.  But as Cris Collinsworth got right, the Redskins offensive coaches simply will not and cannot call plays that take a lot of time to develop because the offensive line can't protect for more than a split second or two. 

This results in the defense blanketing our receivers within the first 10 yards, and easily sniffing out screen passes. With one game to play, it definitely seems like the Skins are a collection of individuals who are just hoping to keep their jobs after their coaches lose theirs.  Or maybe they are like a lot of people who think I really hope I don't get fired, but if I do, sweet!  I'm thinking of people like Carlos Rogers, who is a pretty good cornerback, but not great, who is in a contract year, who watched DeAngelo Hall get paid and not him.  Think Rogers is excited about getting the hell away from Washington? I'm hoping that the team gets basically gutted by Bruce Allen and Mike Shanahan, and that the new people they bring make the team super awesome and it goes to the playoffs.  I'd also like to win the Virginia Mega Millions jackpot.

Thursday, December 24, 2009

RIP George Michael



Legendary sports anchor with NBC George Michael died today.  I kind of grew up with him on my tv.  As far as I'm concerned, he was the perfect balance of homer and critic, and he always predicted that the Redskins would win on Redskins Report the Saturday night before a game, no matter how likely.  He and Sonny always did the live Monday evening interview from Redskins Park.  Man, he was great.

As Michael Wilbon said, "Now, George's voice has been silenced the only way it could be. But if you close your eyes and listen real closely, you'll hear Jim Vance and Arch Campbell laughing and see Doreen Gentzler shaking her head, and George Michael taking you out to the Capital Centre or RFK or Cole Field House for one more highlight, one more interview. We were so lucky that it was so good for so long. And nothing like him will ever pass this way again."

Tuesday, December 22, 2009

Giants 45, Dignity 12



Our dignity was crushed, pummeled, whupped, bodyslammed, kicked in the teeth, ripped to shreds.  I'm not even really going to dignify this performance with the usual blog entry.  Here's what you need to know:


Giants start with ball, keep it for 9 minutes, never getting a play over 14 yards, scoring on a running td.

3 and out.

Giants get it back, go 6 or 7 minutes, get another touchdown.  This game is over.  Campbell had no time to throw, got sacked 5 times, and thrown around like a paper bag in a hurricane.  Look at Laron Landry up there--he really thinks that that is how you tackle someone.  He is a bum.  A straight up b-u-m.

The team didn't come to play.  We kind of thought Zorn had got them to keep playing despite the 2009 circus, and they would finish the season with a determined effort because they are professionals/they respect the game/they are auditioning for future jobs somewhere.   No.  'Twas not the case.  These Redskins did not want to play.  Maybe you can't really blame them all that much, but that's the truth.

Fred Davis seemed interested in competing.  He made 5 or 6 catches including a touchdown where he broke a tackle at the goal line.  He also hurdled some dude to get a first down. 

Santana Moss caught a long pass from Todd Collins after almost dropping.  Then he spun the ball on the ground despite being down 24-0.  Seriously, dude?

Campbell got beat up bad, and he gets credit for wanting to come back in the game.  He led the team to two td drives.  He also looked terrible on a couple of throws, including an overthrown screen returned for a touchdown, and a few incomplete passes where his body language said who gives a shit and the ball landed at the receiver's feet.

Then there's fake field goal play.  Down 24-0 with 3 second left in the first half, Zorn orders the FG team the sprint out to the left, leaving Malcolm Kelly and another guy on the "line"  with Hunter Smith and Gano behind them.  Giants called timeout, very similar to the situation in the Broncos game.

And just like in the Broncos game, they went out with the same formation.  Hunter Smith threw it up deep left, it was picked off, and ran back to midfield.  What a total embarassment.  Zorn said in his press conference that it didn't work because the defense was good.  That's like me saying that I can't dunk a basketball because gravity is good.  Screw you, Zorn.  Seriously, eff you.  Did it feel good sticking it to management?  Good, now hit the bricks.  Enjoy coaching Brady Quinn in Cleveland.

There was also a fight after the game was out of hand following a sack by Lorenzo Alexander on third down.  DHall took on Brandon Jacobs who took a couple of swings, but it was Albert Haynesworth that was called for the penalty when he tried to defend Hall.  No penalty called on Jacobs.  This kind of pushed me over the edge and I refused to speak for about 15 minutes. 

One last thing.  Suisham signed with the Cowboys, meaning he will kick the game winning field goal in overtime this Sunday night.

Thursday, December 17, 2009

Big Effing News: Vinny is Out, Bruce Allen is New GM

...And It was Good




Vinny Cerrato has resigned.  Hope lives.  Food will taste better, men will walk taller, music will sound better.  Glory glory halleleujah the wicked witch is dead.  And joy spread throughout the valley, like so much oxen.

Dad: Woo hoo!

This is not really on the same level as, say, deposing Saddam Hussein from his control over Iraq, or the fall of the Berlin Wall and the dismantling of the Soviet Union.  But it would be inaccuarate to say that it is really dissimilar.  Vinny C. was responsible for so many terrible decisions and a philosophy that resulted in shameful neglect of the Redskins' depth.  Perhaps it took this year's embarrassing Junior Varsity offensive line to result in his resignation.

A little over an hour later, it was announced that Bruce Allen was taking over as GM.  I like the move generally.  He helped build the Raiders into a real contender in early 00s with Jon Gruden. His Raiders actually lost to Gruden's Bucs in the 2002 Super Bowl. That was Gruden's first year there after being the Raiders coach. In 2004 Allen joined Gruden in Tampa and they went to the playoffs a couple of times, but got fired with Gruden in 08. This is why Gruden talk will heat up even though he signed an extension with Monday Night Football. It should also be really interesting listening to Gruden do the Skins/Giants game this Monday. Reallllly interesting.

Cerrato said he got to work with some great coaches like Joe Gibbs, Sherm Lewis, and Greg Blache, but not Jim Zorn--the man he hired less than two years ago.  What a dick.  Oh well, peace dude.  Smell ya later.

Tuesday, December 15, 2009

Laughing at the Misery of Others: Redskins 34, Raiders 13




"I think I am going to guarantee a victory for this one."  Me, 12/10/09

"I think this is what's crazy about football: The Redskins were in the biggest freefall of any team in the league around midseason, with an offense that didn't score more than 17 points in any of the first eight games. Now they've lost their best two running backs for the year, have a retiree calling plays, and they've scored 88 points in the last three weeks. And Jason Campbell looks like a player." --Peter King, SI

On Saturday, I played soccer at 8 AM in 25 degrees.  It was freezing.  The team is the third worst in the division.  I'll likely be abandoning it for a new team in the Spring.  But because I'm a professional, with pride, I showed up ready to go, ready to continue my goal streak.  And I did, after blocking a pass by the sweeper, taking one hard dribble toward the goal from left to right, and depositiong and perfectly placed right side foot shot into the right side of the net.  We won 4-2.

The Redskins did the same out in Oakland by out performing a similarly sad sack team that could not stop committing penalties.  The game was relatively close until the 4th quarter when the Skins pulled away, thanks to an injury that forced Gradkowski out and Ja-Terrible Russell in, lots of Raider penalties, an historic sack performance, and smart offensive football.  It was a nasty rainy day in DC.  I had planned on getting up early and meeting Mom for a 11:00 showing of The Road at Bethesda Row, but because Joey had been messing around with circuit breakers the day before, the alarm clock's AM/PM confused me in my tired state, and I overslept.   So instead I did some laundry, ate an egg sandwich, and prepared my luxury yacht for a voyage to the French Riviera. Mom came through with Hanukkah latkes and a promise not to clean anything.  They were excellent and we snarfed them down. New kicker Graham Gano (pronounced G'Noh) started his Skins career with a big kickoff, that pinned the Raiders in deep after good coverage. 


Nothing much happened, except for a Raiders field goal, until Campbell threw a short dump off pass to Quinton Ganther who took it down the middle and to the left for a 40+ yard gain.  A few players later, Campbell threw to Fred Davis for a short touchdown.  7-3.  Fred Davis did an excessively distateful celebration dance, and the 15 yard penalty helped the Raiders start their next drive in great shape.  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ljDKMIaDlSc&feature=player_embedded





Gradkowski hit McFadden for a catch and run for 26 yards.  He was being covered by Landry.  Landry played much closer to the line of scrimmage as a strong safety, and played much better overall, causing a fumble that we almost recovered before going out of bounds.  However, Gradkowski drove them down to the goal line, and Fargus scored on a short run.  10-7 Raiders.


Gano responded with a pleasing premier kick--a 45 yarder in the mud to tie it at 10.  And late in the half, after Campbell hit Thomas for a big first down, Campbell found Davis again in the back corner of the end zone after stepping up in the pocket.  This time Davis spiked it instead of dancing.  17-10 at the half.


 What was huge for the Skins, though, was that toward the end of the half, one of our guys grabbed Gradkowski hard by the leg before he got rid of the ball and he was done for the day.  In came JaMarcus, who is crazy-bad at throwing.

The Skins offense was dreadful on the first two 2nd half drives.  Janikowski hit a really long field goal to make it a 17-13 game.

With about 7 minutes left in the third, the Raiders were driving again at our 28.  But here is where the title of this blog really starts to make sense:

-sack by Andre Carter
-false start penalty -ineligible man downfield penatly
-sack by Brian Orakpo
-completed pass ruled incomplete after replay challenge -incomplete pass
-punt for touchback All this happened consecutively. 


I often howled with delight during this sequence, thankful that it was the opponent going backwards for once. So the skins started a long 80 yard drive, and had the ball around midfield when the 3rd quarter ended.  Kelly made a nice grab over the middle for a first down, and Moss made a great catch and run inside the 10, weaving in and out, getting a first down at the 2.  Ganther took it in on second down for the TD.  24-13.

Russell then threw an interception to Landry--he made a nice play to jump forward to descending throw down the middle of the field.  A 30 yard pass to Moss helped the Skins moved down to the goal line, and Ganther scored on another short run.  31-13. Russell went back to pass again (more sadistic laughter) and Orakpo nailed him on the blind side, causing a fumble.  Andre Carter couldn't pick it up for what would have been an easy touchdown, and the Raiders got it back. 

The Raiders punted, and Randle El did it again--he was running full speed on the punt return and the ball slammed off of his numbers and the Raiders recovered.  It was our, day, however, because the Raiders couldn't move the ball.  Russell was sacked again on 4th down.  After a drive of basically only runs, the Skins got another field goal, and that was that.  Game over. It was nice to get a win.  It always feels good no matter how bad the rest of the year has gone.  Also satisfying is the opportunity to play spoiler to both the Giants and Cowboys and the joy that comes with ruining something for someone that you hate. 


Spite is really underrated.  This holiday season, take the time to feel the toasty warm glow that comes with destroying something desired by someone you loathe.

Another thing, Brian Orakpo was a total beast.  Back in 2006, we watching the Redskins close out a terrible season, and witnessing a defense that couldn't generate any pass rush or make any stops.  The RClub was silently watching the clock run down.  I spoke up, and said, we need some big monster of a man, someone named Beastmaster Johnson, who is 7 foot 3, 450 pounds, who just picks up the center and the guards off the ground, clunks their heads together like Moe in the 3 Stooges, and destroys the quarterback.  We didn't get that exactly with Orakpo, but he is doing really really well.  11 sacks as a rookie, 4 against the Raiders.  Very exciting and hopeful.



Steve said:
I was slightly encouraged by Campbell's performance, especially because he's using the young receivers more effectively. He also looked significantly less tentative in general. Maybe that's due to the Raiders sucking, but it could also be a sign that he's finally getting comfortable with the offense. I still don't think he'll be back next season, but that's mostly because I don't think Zorn will be back. If Zorn comes back, I think it's possible we keep Campbell, but still draft a young QB to take the reigns at some point.


Monday, December 7, 2009

What is Below Rock Bottom? Saints 33, Redskins 30 OT



What is below rock bottom?  Subterranean fresh water wells?  Aquifers?  Hot liquid magma?  Earlier in this blog, I used the term rock bottom to describe the state of the Redskins, probably after losing to the toothless Chiefs at home, or after getting into a fight with the Atlanta Falcons coaching staff in week 9.  The Skins lost two division game heartbreakers in the last two weeks because they couldn't play a full 60 minutes and hold on to a lead.  But today, December 6, with nothing but pride on the line against the undefeated New Orleans Saints, I think we found a way to chisel and hammer through the bedrock, go beyond rock bottom, and burrow our sorry asses all the way to China.

Most of what occurred today was generally positive.  Campbell played really well, spreading the ball to a lot of different receivers, not taking sacks, and making plays for touchdowns in the red zone.  Hitting long sideline routes with perfect touch, releasing the ball quickly and in stride on crossing routes, getting the ball down the field.  Devin Thomas had his best game ever, scoring two touchdowns, and perhaps persuading me to stop calling him Idiot Thomas, at least for the time being.

There are a lot of things to point the damning finger at--Suisham missing the field goal that would make it a 10 point game with 2 minutes to go, Campbell's late interception, Landry's continued incompetence and carelessness, terrible refereeing, safety Kareen Moore getting totally punked on an interception fumble return for a touchdown.  But I point my finger at the gutless playcalling.  A 10 point lead would have been good enough, one might say.  Against Drew Brees, first and goal from inside the 5--you go for the kill.  When you are 3-8, trying to knock off an 11-0 team, you go for the kill.  When you are a psychotic evil villain with a plot to take over the world or ransom a nuclear weapon, and you have James Bond cornered, you GO FOR THE KILL!  You don't turn on a slowly moving laserbeam, leave the room, and assume your diabolical scheme all went to plan.  James Bond or Drew Brees--they have the tools to strike fast.  You bring down the hammer, or the whole thing goes to shit!

It was first and goal from the 4, Redskins 30, Saints 23.  Once again, I type, this was where the Redskins coaches opted not to take this game.

2:52 4th Was 1st & 4 at NO4 Rock Cartwright Off Right Tackle to NO3 for 1 yard
2:46 4th Was 2nd & 3 at NO3 New Orleans Saints timeout.
2:46 4th Was 2nd & 3 at NO3 Rock Cartwright Off Left Tackle to NO5 for -2 yards 2:04 4th Was 3rd & 5 at NO5 Rock Cartwright Off Right End to NO4 for 1 yard
1:56 4th Was 4th & 4 at NO4 Two-Minute Warning
1:56 4th Was 4th & 4 at NO4 Shaun Suisham 23 yard field goal is MISSED. Holder-Hunter Smith

3 games in a row lost this way.  Imagine if we had a coach who had the ability to comprehend the notion of urgency.  We could have won all 3 of these games and be 6-6.

It was a cold, sunny day following a minor snow storm.  I drove up to Rockville and finally dropped off 2 bags of clothes at Goodwill, and then headed over to the Club.  Joey and I helped Dad prepare some chili for lunch, which was excellent.  We stood around the living room tv, watching the Skins stop Brees on their first drive.  However, Fred Smoot dropped an interception opportunity, one of many missed opportunities.

The Skins O came out on fire, however with a couple of passes to Fred not so Sleepy Davis and Devin not really that much of an Idiot Thomas, plus a facemask and pass interference penalty.  On third and goal from the 8, they capped a 94 yard drive when Davis crossed the zone from right to left, caught the ball in stride, and took it to the left pylon for the score.  The Skins held the Saints again on 3 plays, forcing a punt.

The next drive featured mostly passes, with completions to Davis, Randle El, and Marko.  A field goal made it 10-0.  The Saints scored on the next two drives, first with a field goal.  Then, after we crushed Reggie Bush for a loss on a punt return, Brees did was Brees do.  After a few short completions, he got Landry to bite hard on a double move.  Landry is getting worse--he shouldn't be playing free safety, and it shows.  Marques Colston got wide open and scored with ease.  10-10.  Brees was under occasional pressure, but when he had time to throw, he had all day to throw, making pump moves and double moves very easy to execute.
The Skins offense answered right back though--all throwing.  A short pass to Davis, a couple short passes to Moss, then a long sideline route to Moss dropped in right between the corner and safety.  On second and goal, the Saints came with an all out blitz, but the we were ready, as Thomas snuck around the o-line from left to right, got a short screen pass type play in stride, and dove it in at the right pylon.  Great play, 17-10.

Wow, that photo is really small.  Too bad.  Anyway, now its time to discuss the beginning of the great body blows/gut punches/rib shots, one of which literally brought me to my knees in despair it happened. 



Gutpunch 1:  We were all feeling pretty good with a stop, and a punt that looked to be really short.  But when punts are really short, things go badly for us.  Kareem Moore knew it was coming down near him, and he tried to get really small, but that strategy couldn't prevent the ball from dropping perfectly square on his back, and the Saints took over. 

D stopped the Saints with a sack on third down, with a delayed blitz from Landry.  But Landry made the play by running shoulder first again into Brees and not trying to make a text book tackle.  Brees staggered back with three or four steps and finally fell down, but holy shit, Landry!  I can't believe how shitty he is playing. 

Gutpunch 2: On third and 26, Brees threw down the middle.  The pass was short, Kareem Moore and another player dove for it.  Moore came up with it and starting running down the field toward the left sideline.  He got held up by Robert Meacham, and Moore put his back to Meacham as he tried to gain his footing or break free.  Instead, Meacham snatched the ball right out of his arm, and took it the other way.  I screamed in horror, and collapsed to the floor.
Ughhh.  It hurts to look at this.  Dad was looking for the proper words to describe Moore, finally settling on made him look like a sissy.  Other ways of describing it are got ganked, jacked, done like a ho, made Meacham's bitch, bitchslapped, punked.

Then, we threw the red flag, first hoping that the throw had hit the ground, then hoping that the intended receiver had touched Moore and therefore he was down by contact, and the strip heard 'round the Beltway would have never happened.  But it did happen.  The touchdown was confirmed.  17-17 at the half.

In order for your team to upset an 11-0 team, you need this kind of freak play to happen for you, not against you. 

The Skins offense proved resilent in their first second half drive, including a tear drop go route to Thomas on the right side.  However, on third and goal, Moss did a post pattern while Campbell threw a fade.  The field goal was good, 20-17.  The Saints tried to come out running, but the D stuffed 4 runs in a row, and tookover on downs.

The big play here was Campbell finding a wide open Thomas deep down the right sideline from a busted coverage.  On Third and 7 from 10 or so, Campbell found Thomas again on a crossing route from right to left, and Thomas tip toed down the sideline and pass 3 defenders to get in for the score.  27-17.

The Saints hit a bunch of medium passes, but had to settle for a field goal.  We got the ball back, and on third and 11, made a play that made it feel like things were gonna go our way--Campbell found a streaking Randle El on a wide open post pattern.  The safety caught up to him to save a touchdown, but things were looking great as the 3rd ended.

On first and goal, Campbell threw a pass right into the chest of a Saints defender.  If the ball had been caught, it would have been a 95 yard interception return for touchdown.  It was at that point, Dad and I agreed that we were "even" on breaks.  Looking back, and considering how I feel this rotten Monday afternoon, I'm not so sure.  But at the time, that's where we were emotionally.  The second two plays were gutless runs by Mason.  Field goal good, 30-20.

The Saints did their Saints thing on the next drive, with methodical first down conversions on one or two plays.  On third and goal, Brees went for his usual post up play to Colton in the endzone, but it was knocked away by Byron Westbrook.  Field goal, good, 30-23.

With 6:52 left, Dad said we can run the ball and run the clock out.  That would have been nice.  Campbell started with a play action rollout pass to Sellers who made a nice catch down by his shins for the first down.  A positive run by Ganther, a short pass to Kelly, a smoke screen pass to Thomas + face mask penalty--everything looked great.  3 more runs by Ganther, first and goal.

Gutpunch 3:  We got to talking of clock management, and we had figured out that with 2:39 to play, we didn't have to run another play before the two minute warning.  But that wasn't true because the Saints called timeout with 2:46 left after the first run that was stopped.  So Cartwright ran again, this time for a loss of two.  Now, it was third and goal from the 5--this had to be a pass!  It had to.  We were going for the win, right?  No, the playcaller called for a third run, also stopped. 

Gutpunch 4: Suisham came on to kick a 23 yarder.  It would have put the Saints down by 2 scores with less than 2 minutes to play.  Its basically an extra point.  Just before the snap, Dad said, "This is huge!"  Uh oh. 



The kick went straight up, on a line, to the right of the right upright.  No good.  At this point, Joey had to leave for a dinner in Baltimore.  I turned to Dad and said we gave up the chance for the touchdown, this is what happens. 

Brees didn't waste much time.  It took 33 seconds to send Meacham down the middle of the field, after getting Landry to bite again, for the east score.  Tie game.

Campbell got the ball back with a chance to win.  An 11 yard pass to Cartwright plus a facemask penalty got us to the Saints' 45. 

Gutpunch 5: Next play, Campbell tried to get the ball to Davis in the flat, throwing off his wrong foot.  Jonathan Vilma picked it off and stepped out of bounds.  Fortunately, we stayed alive a little longer because the Saints couldn't move too far, and a 57 yard field fell way short.

Overtime.  On first down Campbell, completed a pass to Moss for 10, and then Ganther ran for 6. 

Gutpunch 6: On Third and 5, Campbell rolled out, and found Sellers for a short gain, Sellers was hit hard--low. His legs went up, and his arms started to come down.  His elbow, then the other arm, and the ball came out.  The ref immediately blew the whistle and the play ended.  We were thinking, please get the play off, please, hurry, hurry.  No.  The Saints called time out, and eventually the play was overturned, and the Saints got the ball.  Look at this photo.  Dude is down by contact.  What could the refs have been thinking beyond the conspiratorial?

The Saints drove all the way down and kicked a short field goal to win.

There's this really annoying saying by Mark Twain that people like to quote: "Dance like nobody's watching; love like you've never been hurt. Sing like nobody's listening; live like it's heaven on earth."  Redskins fans, I mean real-real Redskins fans and not the one's who will throw up their hands and the tell the world that they are no longer "gonna put up with this shit," have to say to themselves, this one really hurts, but at least it didn't cost us the playoffs, and there is hope for the future if you think about Haynesworth, Campbell, Thomas, Davis, Orakpo. 

Wednesday, December 2, 2009

Roundtable: The Jason Campbell Question








This is what the Post Sports Bog says today: The Redskins' offensive line has been in tatters since Pro Bowl left tackle Chris Samuels and right guard Randy Thomas suffered season-ending injuries early in the schedule. Campbell has been sacked 30 times - the league's third-highest total. "Not to knock the line, because they are trying their hardest to protect him and give him an opportunity to throw the ball," Sherman Smith said. "Those guys are trying. But Jason - he's a man. "He's a very good football player, and if he wasn't making the plays that he's made, heck, we wouldn't have the three wins we have. He gives us a chance on Sunday. It means something to him. And that means a lot to us." Steve and I were hashing out all of the issues surrounding Campbell's future, and agreed it probably doesn't matter what the current coaches think. But I'm thinking the chances are fair/solid that a new coach will look at the totality of the circumstances with this team and decide Campbell is the best option.








Yep, that's where I come out. He's the best we can get under the circumstances. I would stay with him. Get him some help up front, and on the edges and see what he can do. And, dump the WC offense. He does not have the skills to succeed in that.





And to regurgitate what I told Dan, I can't fathom a scenario in which a new GM/new coach would assess the quarterback situation and conclude, after reviewing six years worth of Jason Campbell footage under Gibbs (decent O-line protection) and Zorn (patchwork, porous O-line protection) that Campbell merits another year as a starter. And I'd be stunned if he accepted a demotion to back-up on our team, because he could presumably be a backup on a lot of other teams, and why would he choose ours after we publicly humiliated him three times? While Dan's position is tenable - that a new GM/new coach could evaluate our dire QB situation and decide that Campbell is the best option at the moment - I sincerely doubt it will happen. There are three scenarios, as far as I'm concerned: 1) Snyder hires a new GM who hires a Shanahan/Holmgren type of a coach to install a West Coast offense not dissimilar from the one we ran the past two seasons. Is there ANY chance they look at Campbell and determine that his skills suit a West Coast offense? He's got a big windup, he doesn't get rid of the ball quickly, he has horrible pocket awareness, and takes too long to process information/make reads/execute throws generally. So in that scenario, Campbell is out. In the 2nd scenario, Snyder hires a new GM who, in turn, hires a new coach in the Gibbs/Norv Turner mold, a coach who installs a power run/play action style offense. I think we would all agree that Campbells skills are best suited to that style of an offense, with the big arm, big windup, relative accuracy, etc. OK, great. But Campbell had his shot to excel in that offense under Gibbs/Saunders, and he was just average. And he actually regressed from 2005 to 2007 if you think about it. Now, I suppose Campbell could experience a renaissance under that system if it's reinstalled, but after 7 years in the NFL, does he really deserve that shot? And would a new coach eschew an opportunity to acquire a more reliable, more established QB in Year 1 of his tenure for the small chance that Campbell suddenly has a break out year? I say it's unlikely. And the 3rd scenario, also known as the nightmare scenario, is if Snyder retains Cerrato as puppet-GM. In that case, I say there's a 0 percent chance Campbell is resigned. Cerrato tried to move Campbell multiple times last offseason, and has seen first-hand what Campbell can't do, and there's just no way.
So, Campbell is a goner.







Well, I agree with all of your building blocks analysis, but to be a goner, the Skins have to have a replacement. You can't replace him with nothing. And, I don't see how they can do better than Campbell in either the free agency market or in the draft; so, I think we are stuck with Campbell as the best we can do at the moment, and whoever the coach is next year, he's gonna have to install an offense that maximizes Campbell's strengths and minimizes his weaknesses, which at bottom has to mean the WC offense is gone. No matter what we do, we have so many holes on offense that I see no chance for big improvements there. We are going to continue to struggle on offense; Any success will come by having a defense that allows a mistake free offense to score a few points on short fields.







Also in response to Steve: 6 years?

2005--on the bench all year
2006--started/played in 6 games
2007--started/played in 13 games
2008--started/played in 16 games
2009--started/played in 11 games

Assuming he finishes out the year--that's a tiny bit more than 3 seasons. 3 seasons with 3 systems, and 1.5 seasons with a JV offensive line.







All good points, dad, but I challenge your assertion that they can't do better than Campbell in free agency or the draft. What has Campbell done??? Sure, he's acted professionally in difficult circumstances, and he's likeable, has strong biceps and triceps, etc. but there will be a few aging QBs that will get cut from their teams, and there will be QBs available in the draft. Keeping Campbell around will prolong the inevitable, and potentially stunt the rebuilding process. And make no mistake, this team NEEDS to rebuild.

In response to Dan: OK so next year would be his 6th year, not 7th. My point is, he's been in the league 6 years! That makes him a middle-aged QB, and what has he done? Granted he didn't start each game in each of those seasons....so what?! There are some rookie QBs who have entered the league in the past few years who've played well, much better than Campbell played in this, his 5th season. Clearly, if Campbell was NFL-ready, he would have played earlier. It took him awhile to grasp things, and when he finally had a sufficient grasp of the offenses to merit playing time, he was just OK. And he plateaued very quickly, and then arguably regressed.

Also, remember how smooth the offense looked with an aging, girly-armed Todd Collins? Those guys are a dime a dozen, and they're STILL more efficient QBs than Campbell.







You're still not buying the "if you can't be with the one you love, love the one you're with" idea. First of all in football years, it would be his 4th year. And Those rookies that step in and do great--Ryan and Flacco--the chances of that happening are always teeny-tiny. Again, its nice for other teams who have found success in the draft, but the chances of a draft pick being better than Campbell? Small.








I 100% agree, the chances of draft pick being better than Campbell for NEXT SEASON is small. But we're talking long-term strategy here, aren't we? it makes absolutely no sense for either Campbell or the redskins to extend the dysfunctional marriage. campbell shouldn't do it because he knows he's not in our long term plans, and he's an unrestricted free agent, meaning htis could be his last chance for a payday and will seek greener, more functional pastures. and the redskins shouldn't do it because campbell could delay the rebuilding process. we need a fresh face, new QB. change for change's sake. look how well that worked with OBAMA!!! :(








Uh oh, you lost me on OBAMA.








Actually he is a restricted free agent--Skins can match offers I'm thinking long term too! I'm thinking we need two new offensive tackles to protect an average/good QB for 10 years. Putting Jimmy Clausen in there or Bradford in there to be protected by Stephon Heyer and Levi Jones would cause another Patrick Ramsey syndrome.







all I know is, if I have to watch Jason Campbell play football again next year, I'm going to have an epic meltdown. He makes football miserable.








Well, Steve, that's a pretty good standard. If you look at football as entertainment, which I certainly do, there is very little that is entertaining in Campbell. He doesn't make the plays he should, then he makes some plays he shoudn't, but not enough to overcome his failures on the nuts and bolts stuff; completing an 8 yard button hook for a first down.








ok, like who? Assume the Hasselbeck option is not possible.








Kurt Warner (admit it, it's possible), Jeff Garcia, Matt Hasselbeck (I will not assume what you want me to assume!), Kyle Orton, Todd Collins, David Carr, Marc Bulger, Jake Delhomme (eww), Sage Rosenfels?, David Garrard?, other people. I don't know, but there are always surprise releases at the end of the year. it's a great time to unload pricey QB busts because of the cap ramifications. An opporutnity to shed salary. Let's swoop in!









I suppose anything is possible, but how many of these guys would mean improvement?


Warner could retire, Garcia could be the perfect stop gap if he is still in shape, Hasselbeck would be great for a little while, Orton is going nowhere, Bulger is probably going nowhere, and the rest of the guys are not improvements in my opinion.







Campbell is going nowhere! He's not good! He's not good at football!!!!!! That's what your either forgetting, or refusing to admit. Like dad said he misses wide open throws and never seizes big play opportunities. occasionally he makes plays that exceed our expectations, but they're always followed by more shitty plays. name me a quarterback in the NFL, starter or backup, who can't do that? And campbell comes at an extraordinarily high cost to me: the cost of not being able to enjoy football.







So your official stance is:


1. Don't re-sign Campbell

2. Don't draft a QB with 1st round pick

3. Hope somebody falls off of a truck and starts for at least 1 year, and then draft a QB in 2011?







:)